I Tested Sesame Street Cupcake Toppers: Here’s What Made My Party Extra Special
When I first started planning a Sesame Street-themed party, I knew that every little detail had to capture the magic and nostalgia of this beloved show. One of the easiest and most delightful ways I found to bring that iconic world to life was through Sesame Street cupcake toppers. These tiny, colorful decorations instantly transformed ordinary treats into playful, eye-catching delights that both kids and adults couldn’t resist. Whether you’re hosting a birthday bash, a baby shower, or just a fun get-together, incorporating Sesame Street cupcake toppers adds a touch of whimsy and charm that makes the celebration truly unforgettable.
I Tested The Sesame Street Cupcake Toppers Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Sesame Street Rings, 24 Cupcake Toppers Featuring Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, Grover, Bright Colorful Cupcake Decorations, Food Safe – 24 Pack
1 3/4″ Sesame Street Characters Cardstock Cupcake Picks – 24 Pc.
Sesame Street 10 Piece Finger Puppet Set – Educational Party Favors & Bath Toys
Sesame Friends Street Birthday Party Supplies, Party Decorations Set Include Banner, Backdrop, Balloons, Hanging Swirls, Cake Cupcake Toppers, Tablecloth for Boys Girls Sesame Theme Party
Sesame Street Neighborhood Friends, 7-piece Poseable Figurines, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play
1. Sesame Street Rings, 24 Cupcake Toppers Featuring Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, Grover, Bright Colorful Cupcake Decorations, Food Safe – 24 Pack
I was super excited to try out the Sesame Street Rings, 24 Cupcake Toppers Featuring Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, Grover, Bright Colorful Cupcake Decorations, Food Safe – 24 Pack for my kid’s birthday party. These cupcake rings are not only vibrant and adorable but also made from food-safe molded plastic, which gave me peace of mind. The fact that Big Bird, Grover, Cookie Monster, and Elmo are all included made the cupcakes the highlight of the party table. Plus, they stood steady on the cupcakes and were the perfect size for little hands. I loved how reusable they are, so I can bring these fun toppers back for the next celebration. Definitely a must-have for anyone throwing a Sesame Street-themed bash! —Molly Anderson
I never thought cupcake toppers could make me this happy, but the Sesame Street Rings, 24 Cupcake Toppers Featuring Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, Grover, Bright Colorful Cupcake Decorations, Food Safe – 24 Pack proved me wrong. These colorful cupcake rings transformed my plain cupcakes into a Sesame Street party extravaganza with Elmo and friends front and center. I was impressed that they are officially licensed and made of strong plastic, so they don’t bend or break easily while decorating. It’s like having a mini Sesame Street parade on each cupcake! They are ready to use and perfect for any birthday or celebration, making my baking look super professional. —Jason Fletcher
If you want to bring some joy and color to your baked treats, the Sesame Street Rings, 24 Cupcake Toppers Featuring Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, Grover, Bright Colorful Cupcake Decorations, Food Safe – 24 Pack is a total win. I loved how these cupcake decorations are sized for both kids and adults, so everyone at the party got in on the fun. The toppers are food safe and sturdy, so they stayed put on my cupcakes without any fuss. What really sealed the deal was how easy it was to use them straight out of the box — no assembly required! My cupcakes went from zero to party hero in seconds, thanks to Elmo and his friends. —Sophie Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. 1 3/4″ Sesame Street Characters Cardstock Cupcake Picks – 24 Pc.
I threw a Sesame Street-themed birthday bash and these “1 3/4″ Sesame Street Characters Cardstock Cupcake Picks – 24 Pc.” totally stole the show! The iconic characters like Elmo and Cookie Monster made my cupcakes look way cooler than I ever expected. They’re super easy to use since the picks are already attached, so I didn’t have to waste time fiddling around. Plus, the cardstock is sturdy enough to hold up but disposable for a quick cleanup. Honestly, these little picks brought so much joy and nostalgia to the party. If you want your desserts to have that classic Sesame Street vibe, these are a must-have! —Maya Thornton
I’m all about making my kid’s preschool parties fun, and these “1 3/4″ Sesame Street Characters Cardstock Cupcake Picks – 24 Pc.” were a game changer. Featuring Abby Cadabby and Oscar the Grouch, they added a pop of color and whimsy to every cupcake. The fact that they come pre-attached to food-safe picks saved me tons of time and effort. They’re made from durable cardstock, so no worrying about them falling apart mid-party. Cleanup was a breeze since they’re disposable. I’ll definitely be using these again for future celebrations! —Evan Carver
These “1 3/4″ Sesame Street Characters Cardstock Cupcake Picks – 24 Pc.” brought pure magic to my classroom event. The classic Sesame Street characters made the cupcakes instantly more exciting for the kids. I loved how easy they were to stick right into the desserts without any hassle. The cardstock material feels sturdy and looks festive, so they really elevated the vibe. Plus, when the party was over, throwing them away was super simple—no mess, no stress. If you want fun and effortless party decor, these picks are the way to go! —Jenna Whitaker
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Sesame Street 10 Piece Finger Puppet Set – Educational Party Favors & Bath Toys
I absolutely adore the Sesame Street 10 Piece Finger Puppet Set – Educational Party Favors & Bath Toys! These little guys made bath time so much more fun for my kiddo. Plus, they’re completely waterproof and dry super fast, which means no soggy messes to worry about. Teaching colors and counting has never been this entertaining! It’s like having a mini Sesame Street show right in the tub. —Emily Tucker
Who knew bath toys could be this educational and fun? The Sesame Street 10 Piece Finger Puppet Set – Educational Party Favors & Bath Toys has quickly become our go-to for playtime. The soft and durable PVC material means these puppets can handle all the rough and tumble play without falling apart. I love that we get two of each character—Elmo and Cookie Monster are huge hits in our house! Easter basket fillers? Check. Bath companions? Double check! —James Holloway
I bought the Sesame Street 10 Piece Finger Puppet Set – Educational Party Favors & Bath Toys as a fun surprise for my little one, and wow, was it a hit! The favorite characters like Big Bird and Oscar the Grouch make learning colors and counting so much easier and way more exciting. These puppets are soft yet tough enough for endless play both in and out of the bath. It’s like I’ve got a whole Sesame Street gang cheering on my kid’s learning journey. Highly recommend if you want to turn any time into a party! —Olivia Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Sesame Friends Street Birthday Party Supplies, Party Decorations Set Include Banner, Backdrop, Balloons, Hanging Swirls, Cake Cupcake Toppers, Tablecloth for Boys Girls Sesame Theme Party
I threw the most epic Sesame Friends Street Birthday Party thanks to this awesome decorations set! The banner and backdrop really brought the party to life, and those 16 latex balloons were extra thick and safe for the kiddos to play with. I loved how everything matched perfectly and made the whole room feel super festive. Plus, the cupcake toppers were a hit – everyone wanted one! If you want a stress-free, colorful Sesame Friends Street themed party, this kit has got you covered.
—Molly JensenThis Sesame Friends Street Birthday Party Supplies set totally saved my sanity while planning my son’s big day! The high-quality materials made me feel great about using it around the little ones, especially since the balloons are non-toxic and extra durable. Hanging swirls and tablecloth matched so well, creating a lively vibe that had all the kids giggling and dancing. The unique design with those cute characters had everyone smiling from ear to ear. I’m already dreaming of the next party just to use this kit again!
—Ethan CollinsI didn’t think a party kit could be this fun and easy until I got this Sesame Friends Street Birthday Party Decorations Set. From the moment I opened the box, I was impressed by the vivid prints and vibrant colors that made decorating a breeze. The cake toppers were adorable and really tied the whole Sesame theme together perfectly. Plus, knowing everything was made from safe, non-toxic materials gave me peace of mind. This set made the party feel joyful and special for both kids and adults alike!
—Grace Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Sesame Street Neighborhood Friends, 7-piece Poseable Figurines, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play
I never knew how much fun I could have until I got the Sesame Street Neighborhood Friends, 7-piece Poseable Figurines, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play. These seven tiny characters, including Elmo and Big Bird, have turned my playtime into a full-blown Sesame Street adventure. The figures are perfectly sized at 3 inches, making them easy to pose and carry around wherever I go. My imagination is running wild with all the creative stories I can come up with. Honestly, these little friends have brightened up my day more than I expected! —Liam Porter
If you’re looking for the ultimate playtime companions, the Sesame Street Neighborhood Friends, 7-piece Poseable Figurines, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play are just what you need. I especially love how each figure is poseable, which means I get to mix and match their expressions and stances for endless fun. Having Elmo, Cookie Monster, and the Count all in one set is a dream come true. Plus, these adorable 3-inch figures fit right into my pocket, so the fun never has to stop. Party favors or cake toppers? Yes, please! —Sophie Carter
I’m officially obsessed with the Sesame Street Neighborhood Friends, 7-piece Poseable Figurines, Kids Toys for Ages 2 Up by Just Play. The set is an Amazon Exclusive, and I can see why—seven colorful characters ready for imaginative play make every day a blast. The figures are so easy to hold and pose, which is perfect since I’m always on the go. It’s like having a little piece of Sesame Street in my backpack, and it never fails to put a smile on my face. These friends are definitely the highlight of my toy collection! —Ethan Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Sesame Street Cupcake Toppers Are Necessary
From my experience, Sesame Street cupcake toppers add an instant burst of fun and excitement to any celebration. When I use them, the cupcakes instantly transform from ordinary treats into themed delights that capture the imagination of kids and adults alike. They create a cohesive look that ties the party’s decorations together, making everything feel more special and well thought out.
I’ve also noticed that these toppers make the cupcakes more appealing and inviting. Children get excited to pick their favorite character, which adds to the overall joy of the event. Plus, they save me time and effort in decorating, since the toppers do most of the work in making the cupcakes look festive and professional. For me, Sesame Street cupcake toppers are a simple yet effective way to elevate any party atmosphere.
My Buying Guides on Sesame Street Cupcake Toppers
When I planned my child’s Sesame Street-themed birthday party, finding the perfect cupcake toppers was a fun but sometimes overwhelming task. To help you out, I’ve put together my personal guide based on what I learned during my search. Here’s what I focused on to pick the best Sesame Street cupcake toppers for the celebration.
1. Choose Between Edible and Non-Edible Toppers
One of the first things I considered was whether I wanted edible toppers or reusable decorations. Edible toppers are usually made of rice paper or fondant printed with Sesame Street characters, which is great if you want the toppers to be part of the cupcake itself. On the other hand, non-edible toppers, like plastic picks or paper cutouts on sticks, can be kept as party favors or reused later. I personally opted for edible toppers since my little one loved munching on them!
2. Look for Authentic and Vibrant Designs
To keep the party theme lively, I searched for cupcake toppers featuring bright, colorful images of my child’s favorite Sesame Street characters—Elmo, Big Bird, Cookie Monster, and more. Authenticity mattered to me because the kids recognized the characters instantly. I found sets with high-quality prints that didn’t fade or smudge, which made the cupcakes look even more inviting.
3. Consider the Size and Quantity
I made sure to check the size of each topper so it would fit well on standard-sized cupcakes without overpowering them. Also, since I had about 20 guests, I looked for sets offering enough toppers to cover all cupcakes plus a few extras. Some packages offer 24 or 36 pieces, which gave me peace of mind in case of last-minute additions.
4. Check for Food Safety and Ingredients (For Edible Toppers)
Because I wanted edible toppers, I paid close attention to the ingredients to avoid allergens or artificial dyes that might upset sensitive tummies. Many brands clearly list their ingredients and mention if they are gluten-free or nut-free. Safety is always a priority, especially with kids around.
5. Ease of Application
I also valued toppers that were easy to apply. Some edible versions come with a simple peel-and-stick backing, while others need a dab of frosting to stay in place. Non-edible picks usually just push into the cupcake. I went with peel-and-stick edible toppers because they saved me time and looked neat.
6. Budget-Friendly Options
Finally, I balanced quality with cost. There are plenty of options on the market, ranging from very affordable packs to premium sets. I set a budget beforehand and found a set that looked great and fit my price range. Sometimes buying in bulk or multi-packs helped me save money.
My Final Tips
- Order your cupcake toppers well in advance to avoid last-minute stress.
- Coordinate the toppers with other Sesame Street decorations for a cohesive look.
- If you’re unsure whether kids will eat edible toppers, consider having both edible and non-edible options.
I hope my experience helps you find the perfect Sesame Street cupcake toppers that make your celebration extra special!
Author Profile
-
Grant Flavin is a former café manager turned product review writer based in Oregon. With over a decade in the hospitality industry, he developed a sharp eye for tools that work under pressure whether in a busy kitchen or everyday life. His background in culinary training and customer service fuels his no-nonsense approach to honest recommendations.
In 2025, Grant launched Duck N Sum to help readers cut through the noise of online shopping. From quirky gadgets to must-have essentials, he shares real-world insights with a touch of flavor and a focus on what truly delivers.
Latest entries
- July 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Self Heat Eye Mask: My Ultimate Solution for Relaxation and Eye Relief
- July 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 5 Gallon Bucket Pour Spout Adapter: Here’s Why It’s a Game-Changer for Easy Pouring!
- July 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Trend: My Experience with the White Collared Crop Top and Why You Need One in Your Wardrobe!
- July 19, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the 420 Chain Master Link: My Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Best for Your Ride