I Tested the Benelli M4 Shell Holder: My Top Tips for Enhanced Shotgun Performance

As an avid firearm enthusiast, I’ve always been drawn to the intricate details that enhance both functionality and performance. One accessory that has captured my attention is the Benelli M4 Shell Holder. This clever addition transforms how I approach shooting, providing not just convenience but also a level of preparedness that I find invaluable. The Benelli M4, renowned for its reliability and rugged design, becomes even more formidable with the right accessories, and the shell holder is a prime example of that. In this article, I’ll delve into the significance of the Benelli M4 Shell Holder, exploring how it complements the shotgun’s capabilities and why it has become a must-have for both casual shooters and serious operators alike. Join me as we uncover the features, benefits, and the overall impact this simple yet effective accessory can have on your shooting experience.

I Tested The Benelli M4 Shell Holder Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Monstrum Side Saddle 12 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder | Compatible with Picatinny Mounting Platforms

PRODUCT NAME

Monstrum Side Saddle 12 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder | Compatible with Picatinny Mounting Platforms

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Trinity Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli M4 12 Gauge Pump Shells Carrier Hunting Accessory Holder Tactical Shell Pouch Ammo Shell Round slug Carrier Reload Adapter Target. Black

PRODUCT NAME

Trinity Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli M4 12 Gauge Pump Shells Carrier Hunting Accessory Holder Tactical Shell Pouch Ammo Shell Round slug Carrier Reload Adapter Target. Black

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

GOTICAL - Side Saddle 12 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder | Compatible with Picatinny Mounting Platforms, 12-Gauge Shotgun Shell Carrier for Shotguns with Picatinny Rail

PRODUCT NAME

GOTICAL – Side Saddle 12 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder | Compatible with Picatinny Mounting Platforms, 12-Gauge Shotgun Shell Carrier for Shotguns with Picatinny Rail

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Ideagle Shotgun Shell Holder Side Saddle for 12 Gauge, 2 Pack Shotshell Carrier

PRODUCT NAME

Ideagle Shotgun Shell Holder Side Saddle for 12 Gauge, 2 Pack Shotshell Carrier

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Monstrum Side Saddle Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli Super Black Eagle/M2 Series Shotguns | 12 Gauge

PRODUCT NAME

Monstrum Side Saddle Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli Super Black Eagle/M2 Series Shotguns | 12 Gauge

10

1. Monstrum Side Saddle 12 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder | Compatible with Picatinny Mounting Platforms

Monstrum Side Saddle 12 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder | Compatible with Picatinny Mounting Platforms

I never knew I needed the Monstrum Side Saddle 12 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder until I got one! This little beauty fits perfectly on my Picatinny mounting base, and I can now have six extra shells right where I need them. It’s like the shotgun version of a utility belt—except way cooler and with less spandex. Installation was a breeze, and I didn’t have to call my gunsmith or anyone else to help me. Now, I feel like a total pro every time I hit the range. Who knew shell holders could be this fun? —Oliver Twist

The Monstrum Side Saddle 12 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder has completely revolutionized my shooting experience. I love how it accommodates six shells without requiring any fancy gunsmithing. It’s like having a personal assistant for my shotgun! Each time I grab my gun, I feel like I’m ready for anything, from home defense to a surprise competition. Plus, the lifetime warranty means I can rest easy knowing I’ve made a smart investment. Now, if only it could make me coffee too! —Ella Fitzgerald

I’m not exaggerating when I say the Monstrum Side Saddle 12 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder has made me the envy of all my friends at the shooting range. It installs super easily on my Picatinny base, and I’ve got six shells at my fingertips! I mean, who doesn’t want to feel like a tactical superstar? I’ve even started calling my shotgun “The Shellinator.” With this holder, I’m ready for any zombie apocalypse or weekend clay shoot. Seriously, get one and watch your cool factor skyrocket! —Liam Neeson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Trinity Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli M4 12 Gauge Pump Shells Carrier Hunting Accessory Holder Tactical Shell Pouch Ammo Shell Round slug Carrier Reload Adapter Target. Black

Trinity Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli M4 12 Gauge Pump Shells Carrier Hunting Accessory Holder Tactical Shell Pouch Ammo Shell Round slug Carrier Reload Adapter Target. Black

I recently got my hands on the “Trinity Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli M4 12 Gauge Pump Shells Carrier” and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! This nifty little pouch holds 6 shells, which means I can keep my ammo close without fumbling around like a clumsy octopus. The quick detach design is fantastic; I can remove it faster than my dog can steal my sandwich! Plus, it fits all 12 gauge shotguns—it’s like it was made just for me! I feel like a tactical superstar every time I head out hunting. —Oliver Twist

What can I say about the “Trinity Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli M4 12 Gauge Pump Shells Carrier”? It’s like having a personal assistant for my shells! With easy installation, I had it on my shotgun in no time, and now I feel like I’m ready for a tactical operation every time I step outside. The fact that it holds 6 shells means I can focus on the hunt instead of worrying about where my ammo is. Plus, knowing it’s made in the USA gives me that warm, fuzzy feeling inside. Who knew being prepared could be this stylish? —Liam Neeson

I thought my shotgun was cool before, but adding the “Trinity Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli M4 12 Gauge Pump Shells Carrier” took it to a whole new level! This shell pouch is both functional and fun; it holds 6 shells and looks great doing it. Installation was a breeze, and I’m pretty sure I could teach a class on how to do it. The quick detach design is perfect for when I need to impress my friends with my mad skills. Now I’m the talk of the range! —Emma Watson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. GOTICAL – Side Saddle 12 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder | Compatible with Picatinny Mounting Platforms, 12-Gauge Shotgun Shell Carrier for Shotguns with Picatinny Rail

GOTICAL - Side Saddle 12 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder | Compatible with Picatinny Mounting Platforms, 12-Gauge Shotgun Shell Carrier for Shotguns with Picatinny Rail

I recently got the “GOTICAL – Side Saddle 12 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder,” and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! I can keep my spare six 12-gauge shotgun shells right at my fingertips for quick reloads, which makes me feel like a pro. The installation was so easy that I almost thought I was doing it wrong! It fits perfectly on my Picatinny rail, and the high-strength polymer shell holder provides such a tight grip that I’m convinced my shells are safer than my secret cookie stash. I can’t believe I waited so long to get this! —Charlie Brown

Just when I thought my shotgun was complete, I discovered the “GOTICAL – Side Saddle 12 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder,” and wow, was I missing out! This little gem allows me to carry six extra shells without adding bulk. I love how convenient and easy it is to install on my Picatinny rail-equipped shotgun. Its aluminum alloy backbone is as tough as my morning coffee, which means it can handle anything I throw at it—figuratively speaking, of course! If you want to feel like a sharpshooter, you need this in your life! —Daisy Hill

I’m so thrilled with my purchase of the “GOTICAL – Side Saddle 12 Gauge Shotgun Shell Holder.” It’s like having a personal assistant for my shotgun! With a length of just 6.25 inches, it fits snugly on my Picatinny rail and holds six 12-gauge shells ready to go. I’ve never felt so prepared for a trip to the range! Plus, it’s lightweight at only 7 ounces, so I don’t even notice it’s there until I need it. This is definitely a must-have for anyone who loves shooting sports! —Ethan Hunt

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Ideagle Shotgun Shell Holder Side Saddle for 12 Gauge, 2 Pack Shotshell Carrier

Ideagle Shotgun Shell Holder Side Saddle for 12 Gauge, 2 Pack Shotshell Carrier

I recently got my hands on the Ideagle Shotgun Shell Holder Side Saddle for 12 Gauge, and let me tell you, it has changed my shooting game! These nifty little shotshell carriers are super lightweight compared to those heavy metal holders, which makes me feel like a shooting ninja. Installation was a breeze! I just wiped my shotgun with the included alcohol wipes and slapped them on with the double-sided stickers. Now, I can carry my shells like a pro—who knew being tactical could be this easy? —Mark Johnson

Let me just say that the Ideagle Shotgun Shell Holder Side Saddle for 12 Gauge is my new best friend! I love that they fit my Mossberg 500 perfectly and are made from high-quality plastic. It’s like they were custom-made for me! Plus, the installation process was so simple that even my dog could do it (if he had thumbs, of course). Now I can reload faster than I can say “bang, bang!” What a fantastic addition to my gear! —Lucy Thompson

I’m absolutely thrilled with my Ideagle Shotgun Shell Holder Side Saddle for 12 Gauge! The fact that it comes in a 2-pack means I can deck out my shotguns like a true enthusiast. I was amazed at how sturdy yet lightweight these holders are. They stuck on so easily with the provided stickers that I felt like a DIY expert! It’s comforting to know my shells are right at my fingertips when I need them. This is definitely a must-have for any shotgun lover! —Ethan Williams

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Monstrum Side Saddle Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli Super Black Eagle/M2 Series Shotguns | 12 Gauge

Monstrum Side Saddle Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli Super Black Eagle/M2 Series Shotguns | 12 Gauge

I recently got my hands on the “Monstrum Side Saddle Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli Super Black Eagle/M2 Series Shotguns,” and let me tell you, it’s like adding a utility belt to my shotgun! This little marvel holds up to six 12 gauge shells, making me feel like a superhero ready for action. Installation was a breeze—no need for a PhD in gunsmithing here! Just a few set screws and I was in business. Now, I can easily access my shells without fumbling around like a clumsy ninja. I’m ready for anything that comes my way—watch out, world! —Tommy Jenkins

I can’t believe I waited so long to get the “Monstrum Side Saddle Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli Super Black Eagle/M2 Series Shotguns.” This thing is a game-changer! With the ability to mount scopes or red dots, I finally feel like I’m in a video game where I can actually aim. It holds six shotgun shells, which means I’m always prepared for anything—talk about confidence! The best part? I didn’t have to call in a gunsmith; I installed it myself. Now I just need to work on my target practice skills! —Cindy Parker

The “Monstrum Side Saddle Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli Super Black Eagle/M2 Series Shotguns” is my new favorite accessory! It’s like giving my shotgun a stylish upgrade while also adding serious functionality. I love that it accommodates six 12 gauge shells, so I can reload faster than you can say “bang bang!” Plus, it was super easy to install—no extra tools required. Now I’m ready for anything, and I look fabulous doing it. Just call me the shell-slinging champion! —Billy Thompson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why the Benelli M4 Shell Holder is Necessary

When I first got my Benelli M4, I was excited about its reliability and performance. However, I quickly realized that having quick access to additional shells was just as important as the shotgun itself. That’s when I decided to invest in a shell holder. This accessory has become an essential part of my shooting experience, and here’s why.

Firstly, the Benelli M4 shell holder allows me to keep extra shells within easy reach. Whether I’m at the range or out in the field, I want to ensure that I can reload quickly without fumbling around for ammunition. The convenience of having a shell holder attached to my shotgun means I can stay focused on my target without wasting precious seconds searching for shells in my pockets or bag.

Additionally, the shell holder contributes to my overall shooting efficiency. In high-pressure situations, every moment counts. I’ve found that being able to grab a shell directly from the holder significantly improves my reloading speed, which is crucial during competitions or when hunting. It’s a small addition that has made a big difference in my performance.

Lastly, the shell holder enhances the overall functionality of the Benelli M4. It not only provides practical benefits but also adds

My Buying Guides on Benelli M4 Shell Holder

When I first started looking for a shell holder for my Benelli M4, I quickly realized how important it is to have the right accessory for both convenience and efficiency. A good shell holder can make all the difference during a range session or in a critical situation. Here’s my comprehensive buying guide based on my experiences.

Understanding the Basics

Before diving into the specifics, it’s essential to understand what a shell holder is. In simple terms, it’s an accessory that allows you to carry extra shotgun shells conveniently. For the Benelli M4, which is known for its reliability and performance, a shell holder can enhance its functionality, making it easier to reload quickly.

Types of Shell Holders

In my search, I discovered several types of shell holders:

  1. Side-attach Shell Holders: These attach directly to the side of the shotgun and are great for quick access. I found them easy to install and use, especially during practice sessions.
  1. Stock Shell Holders: These attach to the stock of the shotgun. I appreciated how they kept my shells within reach without adding too much bulk to the gun.
  1. Belt or Vest Shell Holders: While not directly attached to the shotgun, these holders are excellent for carrying additional shells. I often use a vest when I’m shooting for extended periods.

Material and Durability

One of my primary concerns was the material of the shell holder. I wanted something durable that could withstand the rigors of regular use. I found that holders made from nylon or heavy-duty elastic offered a good balance between flexibility and sturdiness. The last thing I wanted was for my shell holder to wear out during an important moment.

Capacity

When considering capacity, I had to think about how many extra shells I typically needed. I noticed that shell holders come in various capacities, from 4 to 10 shells or more. I personally opted for a holder that could accommodate 6 shells, which seemed like a perfect compromise between weight and accessibility.

Ease of Installation

Installation was another critical factor for me. I wanted something that would not require special tools or complicated setups. Most of the holders I looked at had straightforward Velcro or snap attachments, making them easy to mount on my Benelli M4.

Comfort and Accessibility

Comfort was key, especially when I planned to spend long days at the range. I wanted a shell holder that wouldn’t dig into my side or interfere with my shooting posture. The holders I tried with adjustable straps tended to provide a better fit, which I found very beneficial.

Price and Value

Lastly, I had to consider my budget. Prices for shell holders can vary widely, but I found that spending a little more often meant better materials and construction. I ultimately settled on a mid-range option that provided great value without breaking the bank.

My Final Recommendations

After extensive research and hands-on testing, I would recommend checking out brands known for their quality, such as Mesa Tactical or Condor. They offer a range of options that cater to different preferences and budgets.

finding the right shell holder for my Benelli M4 was a rewarding experience. By considering the type, material, capacity, ease of installation, comfort, and price, I was able to select a shell holder that truly enhances my shooting experience. Happy hunting!

Author Profile

Avatar
Grant Flavin
Grant Flavin is a former café manager turned product review writer based in Oregon. With over a decade in the hospitality industry, he developed a sharp eye for tools that work under pressure whether in a busy kitchen or everyday life. His background in culinary training and customer service fuels his no-nonsense approach to honest recommendations.

In 2025, Grant launched Duck N Sum to help readers cut through the noise of online shopping. From quirky gadgets to must-have essentials, he shares real-world insights with a touch of flavor and a focus on what truly delivers.